This post is part of a series about hosting a happy holiday meal, one where you aren’t exhausted by or resentful of the work needed, everyone gets to participate in ways that satisfy, and your values and traditions–and energy and money–are respected.
As Bob Belcher joyfully reminds us in every Thanksgiving episode of Bob’s Burgers, Thanksgiving is a cook’s holiday–but a kind cook makes a meal that fits their guests. That means more than just the technical tasks of cooking: it means knowing your people, appreciating their needs and pleasures, then meal planning to make the meal pleasant and welcoming.
A parenting group I’m part of is exploring holidays right now, and it’s been fun to share our not just our menus but our approaches to the food part of the biggest food holiday of the year. Here’s mine–and I’d love to hear yours!
The Questions that Guide Our Menu
Who’s coming?
As the host, one of your jobs is to ensure that everyone feels welcome and appreciated. Can you solve the puzzle of making dishes that anyone can eat while also ensuring that everyone’s favorite food is served or a happy memory triggered? It might not be possible to it all perfectly–after all, someone is likely to follow a vegetarian diet while someone else’s favorite food is turkey–but do your best to ensure that everyone on the table can be enjoyed by almost everyone. And everyone should be able to eat most items on the table. If you invited someone, their need for gluten-free or dairy-free food should be important enough to you to meet it.
What themes will tie this meal together?
We like traditional holiday meals, but “traditional” varies across regions and groups. (Where I’m from, we eat neither dressing nor stuffing but a third thing calledfilling, which is like if mashed potatoes had a baby with stuffing.) So consider focusing on a tradition–like a New England or Southern or Southwestern focus. Or maybe your theme is childhood memories or indigenous local foods. Or maybe the theme is “subtle tweaks on our family’s traditions.” Whatever it is, a theme gives you some guardrails so you don’t got lost in the options while menu planning and so that, if someone asks what they can bring, you can give them suggestions that keep the final spread focused rather than being a hodgepodge.
What will we most enjoy making?What items will be appreciated if purchased or semi-homemade instead?
If you don’t enjoy making it, don’t make it. Either don’t serve it at all or buy it. I love baking–but not yeast rolls, pies, or pumpkin rolls, though I love to eat them all and have engaged in questionable Facebook Marketplace exchanges for a pumpkin roll. (Seriously, this is how a kidnapper is gonna get me.) Support your economy by buying the things you don’t like to cook from local bakeries or cottage bakers. If you want to serve a turkey but don’t want to cook one, see if local restaurants will sell you one fully ready-to-serve. There is ZERO shame in that, but as I tell judgmental old ladies in the family who ask me if I made the pie myself, “I made the money that bought the pie.” (Or, “Yes, but the recipe is a family secret, and if I tell, my great-grandma’s ghost will haunt me forever.”)
Spend your time cooking the things that are fun for you–including new recipes! (Yes, I try new recipes at holidays, if I trust the source. Because I’m not going to do a dry run of a croquembouche for dinner for three of us! Just be sure you have a backup dish on hand in case it really goes wrong.)
Either skip, delegate, buy, or go semi-homemade for the rest.
And showcase what you truly love to make, including what you’ve grown or preserved yourself already.
What’s non-negotiable? Where can we push tradition a bit?
If everyone on your guest list is down to drop tradition, feel free–but otherwise, let the people who like traditional holiday foods enjoy their day. Find out what is really important to your guests and do your best to meet it. Tinker with recipes within a range that your guests will still find enjoyable, or make two versions of the same dish that share the same prep until the final few steps–for example, plain cranberry sauce and cranberry sauce with oranges and anise, or Brussels sprouts with a dusting of parmesan and another with blue cheese and bacon. And if you personally dislike a dish, rather than futzing with it to increase the chances that you will (since you might not), focus on improving your own technique so that it’s the best version of the dish your guests will appreciate (I’m looking at you, oyster dressing).
Our Menu
Appetizers brought by guests OR crudités and cheese and crackers platter
Pickle plate, with at least 3 items, including one non-cucumber pickle (beets, cocktail onions, etc), plus olives
Cranberry sauce, in all the ways your guests like it: jellied and whole, with an without any added anise, orange peel, walnuts, maple syrup, cinnamon or crushed pineapple
Rolls, biscuits, bread, buns, or a fancy, savory tart
Turkey; if a vegan or vegetarian is included, add a stuffed acorn or honeynut squash
Stuffing, sweet potato casserole, or corn casserole
Mashed potatoes, Duchess potatoes, au gratin potatoes, or an ombre of pureed sweet potatoes, mashed parsnips, and mash potatoes in a casserole dish
Brussels sprouts or green beans
A Jello salad (Why? Because I inherited my great-grandma’s molds and like to use them, plus I live in the Midwest and see assembling fancy Jello salads as an intangible culture tradition)
A green salad of winter greens with a bold dressing
A candy, nut, or snack mix
A chocolate dessert
A fall dessert: pumpkin pie, caramel apple pie, apple crisp with cheddar cheese in the crust, pumpkin whoopie pies, a chocolate pecan pie, etc.
What is your menu planning approach? Menu must-haves? Please share!
This post is part of a short series about having a happy holiday. It’s inspired by questions posted in my parent support group, shared here with permission and without identifying details. If you have a question–or a solution to one!–to share, let me know.
Here is today’s question, plus some follow-ups:
I’m at a loss when it comes to host/hostess gifts. Can you offer some suggestions?
A host/hostess gift thanks someone for their hospitality–their invitation for you to join them in their home, which is an act of vulnerability and generosity. We recognize their efforts in preparing their home, making food, and ensuring our comfort and safety with a small gift.
A good host/hostess gift is one that
is sincerely given
isn’t so expensive as to be a burden to you or an embarrassment to the recipient
is for the host/hostess only, to be given to them without expectation that they share it with the group
is never a criticism or suggests that they might not be prepared (for example, handing them a bottle of wine or a serving utensil and saying, “This is in case you don’t have enough”)
does not presume a level of intimacy that doesn’t exist between you (for example, no personal care items unless you know the person very well)
is not something to be displayed unless, again, you know them very well–and even then, is small (like a Christmas ornament)
is typically consumable, so they can use it, share it, or regift it easily
Some gifts are best if you know the person very well, while others are suitable even if it’s your first time in someone’s home. Here are our favorites to give and receive:
higher-end nuts, chocolates, or candies–nicer than what is typically at your grocery store
cut flowers already in a vase–better if it’s a pretty one you score from a thrift store rather than one from the floral department of the grocery store
old-fashioned holiday candies, like ribbon candies
a small fruit basket (Kumquats are a favorite to share!)
a 0 proof wine or apéritif if you don’t know if they consume alcohol or a bottle of wine or liqueur if you know that they do
a 4- or 6-pack of fun sodas
a box of fancy tea or pound of fancy coffee
a locally made favorite: pfeffernüsse, pecans or chestnuts from a local orchard, popcorn from local growers
if they aren’t from around where they live, a favorite from where they’re from. Someone once sent me grilled stickies from Ye Old College Diner (RIP) in State College, Pennsylvania, while I lived far away, and they will be mentioned in my obituary.
Above, a dessert that you didn’t know you needed. Be a pal and order some for the central Pennsylvanians you love who are far from home.
If you know someone well, you can consider:
one more item in a series of something that they collect (book, kitchen tool, refrigerator magnet)
a framed photo of people or a place they love–maybe even with them in it!
a houseplant, including a cutting from one of yours
an amaryllis, small pointsettia, or other holiday-specific plant
a jar of jam or bottle of real maple syrup
an ingredient they’d enjoy cooking with but aren’t likely to already own (specialty flour, high-end spice)
something homemade: a spice blend, a jar of salsa, your famous hot sauce, a table runner, potpourri that you made, dried flowers, a bottle of homemade Irish cream
something small that you noticed them enjoying in a previous encounter–like a magnet from your visit to the art museum, a small kitchen tool of yours that they complimented when they visited you
I prefer not to receive a hostess gift. How do I tell people not to bring one?
It is good that people desire to express their appreciation for your work as host, so be sure you have a significant reason for saying no, one that doesn’t dismiss their appreciation (“It’s no big deal to host!”) or insult them (“I already have enough junk in my house and don’t need more!”). If you do have a good reason and if you know someone well, you can tell them that you prefer for them to say thanks with words, not a gift. If you don’t know someone well, let them bring you a gift.
If you receive a gift you don’t want, say “Thank you!” without lying that it’s perfect or that you love it or that it’s thoughtful. Then, give it away. Drop it off in your local neighborhood sharing box (“Blessing Box,” in some communities), advertise it for free on Facebook Marketplace (setting the settings so that your friends can’t see it), put it in the common area at your workplace with a sign that says “free,” or regift it to your child’s teacher, your church secretary, the janitor at work, your mail carrier, your garbarge collector, etc. Even if you are irritated that you received a gift you didn’t want, sharing a gift is a chance for you to think about the people in your life who would enjoy it, which is a good practice!
How do I handle a hostess gift that is clearly intended to be shared with the group?
If you want to share it, share it. If you don’t–maybe because it’s alcohol and this event is alcohol-free or because you have the perfect menu planned and this item interrupts it–say, “Thank you! I’m going to go put this away to enjoy later.” If the item is clearly for the moment–like a pan of dinner rolls or a pie–just say, “Thank you! I’m going to put this in the freezer so we can enjoy it later.” When you do enjoy it later, send them a text thanking them for it.
I think this is an important practice because some people really struggle not to impose their food on your menu. Whether this is because they are controlling or because they like helping (remembering that “helping is often the sunny side of control”), it’s a bad habit, and you shouldn’t cater to it.
Is it okay to regift a hostess gift?
Gifts are meant to be enjoyed, so if passing one along is how you enjoy, that’s just great! Just be sure that 1. the giver won’t see you do it, 2. the recipient is likely to enjoy it, and 3. you remove any indicators that it is a regift. Then, give it away while enjoying the idea of it being appreciated by someone else.
This post is part of a short series about having a happy holiday, one where you aren’t exhausted by or resentful of the work needed, everyone gets to participate in ways that satisfy, and your values and traditions–and effort and money–are respected.It’s inspired by questions posted my parent support group, shared here with permission and without identifying details. If you have a question–or a solution to one!–to share, let me know.
In this post, we’re sharing challenges we’ve faced in creating a happy Thanksgiving, Christmas, or other major holiday, in hopes that others can benefit from our experiences. We’re drawing on our childhood and adult experiences, with a focus on the diverse needs of guests and the challenges of helping everyone, regardless of age, having a fun time.
Here’s today’s challenge:
While typically a normal human being, my mother is highly stressed when hosting and passes that along to others. It’s clear that she doesn’t enjoy hosting events, but she also won’t let anyone else take over the duties. We dread going to her house for the holidays. She works through the entire event, but instead of feeling cared for, we feel like we’re a burden. For example, last year, she whisked away my dessert plate while I was still eating my pie! We’re not allowed to eat in the dining room because she got new carpet in it 15 years ago and doesn’t want stains on it, so we end up perched on couches and folding chairs throughout the house, and then she’s anxious that we’re going to spill our food there, too. Instead of eating, she walks around with a Dustbuster in her hand sweeping up crumbs. It’s misery.
Graciously remember that many generations of women likely faced (and saw their mothers face) a lot of judgment about being an “angel of the house,” and they have internalized it–and may also externalize it by being judgmental about other women’s performances of hosting. But the reality is that it’s hard to be gracious to a Thankzilla when she’s raging against both internalized sexism and her guests, even if that rage is the quiet seething of someone who is unloading the dishwasher that you loaded after the dishes have been through the wash cycle, rinsing them, and then reloading it and re-starting the entire dishwasher process because, without her supervision, you surely did not properly scrape and rinse the dishes before loading the dishwasher in the first place. (Ooops. I think we’ve touched a nerve here for me!)
Yeah, it’s hard to be the object of resentment while also being seen as too incompetent to perform any tasks that would lighten her burden.
While I’m not recommending Bad Moms, Christine Baranaski’s character is the epitome of a controlling, insecure mom at the holidays. My favorite line is when she tells her adult daughter “Moms don’t ENjoy; they GIVE joy. That’s how being a mom works and this hideous tree does not give joy to anybody.”
The only way to win at this game is not to play. So, to that extent:
drop the holiday gathering from your rotation of times when you see her. You can see her at a time when the pressure is lower on her, creating a new tradition at a different time of year. You can celebrate a holiday that you love in a way that makes sense for your family. Yes, this will hurt her feelings, but you can say honestly, “I want something different from my Thanksgiving than we’re able to do together, so our family won’t be coming this year. We’d love to do X [a luminary walk at the arboretum, attend the town Thanksgiving Day parade, attend a performance of Amahl and the Night Visitors, participate in the Audubon Society’s annual bird count, sing in the community choir’s performance of Handel’s Messiah, etc.] with you instead.” Be clear that it’s not a scheduling issue as she’ll try to solve it, which only kicks the problem down the road.
host the event. If she asks how she can help, give her a specific task that she will actually enjoy, along with a compliment about it; the key here is that it has to have some level of challenge to it so it will help dissipate her anxious energy. (“You always make the best pumpkin roll! Would you like to make one for the event?” “The kids love your cookies! Could you bake sugar cookies for the kids to decorate, with your help, after the meal while I do the dishes? I’ll bring the icing and the decorations if you bake them.” “We’d like to take a family photo. Could you find a photographer and schedule them for a mini-session at our house? And let everyone know to come dressed for photos. We’ll pay, and the budget is XXX.” “You set such a beautiful table! Could you bring a centerpiece?”)
offer to host, but shift to a nice restaurant, and pay for her meal without telling her the cost. Tell her that it’s a thank you for all the times she’s hosted. If she complains that it costs too much to eat out, tell her, “You’re worth every penny!” Tip the waitstaff HUGELY and, again, don’t tell your mother/MIL. And if she says that she’ll tip them, let her, but them tip them again anyway because they deserve a huge tip at a holiday and probably had to absorb your mother/MIL’s anxious energy and criticism too.
if she insists on hosting, suggest a breakfast or dessert event, which will limit the amount of time spent together, or quickly transition from a meal to something outdoors, like a family walk at a local county park or volunteering at a soup kitchen, so that time spent in her home is limited.
if she hosts, remember that you don’t have to attend or stay very long. You can enjoy as much of the day as you enjoy, then leave. Or you can even make plans to leave early because of another event, like volunteering or visiting a shut-in friend or relative. Drive separately from your partner if needed to ensure a quick getaway.
if she hosts and you choose to participate, ask early how you can help, then do that thing early, giving her updates once it’s done so that her anxiety about whether you are going to deliver is soothed (“I made the cheese balls last weekend, and they’re in the freezer, just waiting for the big day!”) If you live nearby, offer to drop food or other items off early, like the day before, so she can organize them as she pleases. When en route, call and ask if she needs any last minute items, like additional ice or more butter or a box of plastic flatware, which shows that you understand the stress of hosting.
Also, bring a hostess gift that she will actually enjoy–cut flowers already in a vase, a little plant, some pretty stationary, a favorite candy. When you arrive, take her aside and give it to her, letting her know that it’s just for her, to be opened whenever she likes. If she wants to share the box of chocolates or bottle of wine with everyone, that’s up to her, but it should be something that demonstrates that you know her well and appreciate her. Because, even when she’s melting down because someone has violated an unspoken rule, you actually do appreciate her. At least, on other days.
Have a question, challenge, or piece of advice to share about how to enjoy holidays? Please share it!
For years now, we’ve included holiday letter with our Christmas card. We enjoy sharing with our friends the news of our world–our successes and struggles, life changes, political concerns, and reflections on scriptures that spoke to us that year. But this year’s letter is a little different!
These days, our family is substantially changed in form: the older two children are in college and grad school, and while in the past few years we’ve collaborated on our family holiday letter, they’re at a stage to write their own stories. I encourage you to reach out to these young adults to hear them!
A Quiet Life
Life is mostly pleasant in our mid-sized Midwestern town, and especially from the third floor of our 1902 American Four Square where I am writing this letter. From one window, I see the historic main street; from another, a great oak tree that makes me feel like I’m in a treehouse; and, from the third, our backyard, which is just starting to take shape.
This year, we planted a number of fruit bushes, but it’s likely that only a blackberry bush will survive. We had a decent crop of tomatoes, and our neighbor had an even better one and happily shared when we were in need. (Homebuying advice: look for neighbors who like gardening and who plant more than they can eat!) A few volunteer pumpkins popped up–and should have even more next year, as we hosted a jack-o-lantern carving party for the campus gay-straight alliance and tossed the seeds into a corner of the yard. About a dozen varieties of hens and chicks are flourishing in our rock garden, and the morning glories we planted to fill in the privacy fence have taken off, as expected.
Above, jack-o-lanterns carved by our students at a chili-and-carving party at our house. Maybe next year we’ll carve the pumpkins that grow from the seeds of this year’s jack-o-lanterns!
To this growing garden, we added a tank pool, which we kept in use until mid-October before we decided that the lower 70s were as cold as we could handle. We’re toying with ideas to heat the water. Advice is welcome!
We also finally introduced chickens to our henhouse and now get 3 or 4 eggs–white, coppery-chocolate, pistachio, and blue–a day, which gives us enough to share with friends or deliver on our almost-daily walks to our neighborhood free pantry.
Living close to downtown means we can walk to some of our favorite spots: the new Mediterranean restaurant, a coffee shop or one of the town’s two bookstores (Red Fern, for new books, and Ad Astra, for used), and our pastry shop, Seraphim Bakery, which serves a delightful Scotch egg in an Art Deco setting. In the summer and fall, we can walk to the farmer’s market, but we love the fruit and vegetable stand so much that we have to bring the minivan to haul it all home. Downtown is also home to the Steifel Theater, where we sometimes see the city’s symphony. Walking the other direction brings us to a little private college, a beautiful campus of old brick buildings and a lovely pond with a fountain. From our back porch, we can hear the fans cheer at home football games.
We walk often, amping up our step count this year by completing K-State Extension’s Walk Kansas challenge, in which your team attempts to walk the distance of the state–423 miles–over two months. Our team, the Bad Knees Bears, included my siblings and brother-in-law and honored our grandmother, who passed away in May and who, when we were young, wore us out “tramping,” as she called it–taking long walks on country roads and hikes through the woods, despite her serious arthritis. We walk some local trails, but our daily walk is a neighborhood loop with Teddy and Lizzie, our dogs, that helps us get to know the neighbors and the neighborhood trees and flowers. (Hollyhocks are especially popular on our street, which has been a comfort since they were also part of my grandmother’s front porch garden during my childhood.)
We got new neighbors this summer, and it’s a joy to hear their three little children playing in the backyard, singing (“Wife is a highway, and I wanna wide it all night wong!” as the three-year-old sings), riding their trikes, and playing. I miss that stage of parenting: we had a summer of big birthdays–21, 18, and 13, so everyone “leveled up”–and even though we still have a lot of fun, it’s less silly. But, also, we see the reward for that earlier parenting when the youngest fixes his own lunch or the oldest changes their oil and the brake fluid solo.
Locally, we continue to work to reducing COVID infections and their harms. I’m trying to create a local Mask Bloc and share information about COVID and local transmission information and also provide respirators and COVID tests to those who want them. If you do or want to do that kind of work in your community, let’s collaborate! Or if you want to learn more about COVID, share your story, get support for your health, or work through your grief at the many losses from COVID, let me know.
School and Work
The older two kids are in grad school (master’s of arts in history) and undergraduate (social work and anthropology) an hour away, which is a nice distance in case of emergency but not so close that we step on each other. One is working with in a memory care facility, preparing food and serving people with dementia and also assisting a recently widowed professor in transitioning to this new stage of life by sorting and storing and toting her beloved’s things; both jobs are sacred work. The other child works in the registrar’s office, a job we remind them is incredibly cushy for a college student. The youngest child is in 8th grade, enjoying the little bit of time left before we expect a summer or maybe even after-school job. He built a new computer this year (and one last year, too) and enjoys biking, friendship, and game design, winning his teacher’s praise that his most recent game is the best she’s seen in the five years she’s been teaching the course.
Serving as a professor right now is hard; anxiety about decisions from the Department of Education and other federal agencies is high, as funding for important meaningful projects has ended, including a grant from KU Med that I was part of that worked to ameliorate inequities around COVID. We grieve with our colleagues and friends at the cruel and unnecessary cuts intended to undermine higher education.
But the work itself is encouraging. Many K-State students are the first in their families to go to college, and it’s a privilege to support them in this big step. The College of Technology and Aviation is a weird place for scholars in the Liberal Arts, but it’s also fun to learn from colleagues whose knowledge, assumptions, and experiences have been shaped in such different disciplines. Do they feel the same? Hard to say, so I keep a candy dish of Zotz outside my office to foster good will.
The scholarship part of the job remains satisfying, as the work contributes to a better understanding of issues that affect us all: COVID, health inequities, politics, religion, violence, and hate. Despite so much discouragement about academia, we need more, not fewer, people thinking about these topics, whether as researchers or readers and activists.
A Little Travel
We traveled to Kentucky in March to attend my grandfather’s funeral and burial, less than 10 miles from the rural homestead where he was born, near Somerset. It was a lovely funeral, planned in great detail by my grandfather, a lifelong carpenter who always paid attention to little things and cared about beauty. We took the opportunity to visit family in the area and got to enjoy a stay in the Cumberland Mountains
Above, a recording of The Stanley Brother’s “Farther Along,” performed by some cousins at my grandfather’s funeral
In mid-August, we headed again to the Buffalo River in Arkansas, to dip our toes into the first nationally protected river in the US. We recommend it heartily.
A favorite swimming hole along the Buffalo River.
And in October, the Rhetoric of Health and Medicine conference took us north to Minneapolis, a city we’d never visited before. Outside of the conference, we spent time at the Weisman Art Museum; the Bell Museum, a natural history museum with spectacular dioramas; and the Minneapolis Sculpture Garden.
Hare on Bell on Portland Stone Piers at the Minneapolis Sculpture Garden
We love living in the Midwest in part because so many beautiful and diverse places are within a day’s drive. We’re lucky!
Our Goal for 2026: Seeking the Good of Others
Have you felt that people–maybe even yourself–have been a little, uh, ruder in recent years? More short-tempered and less thoughtful? The coarsening of our interactions isn’t just a downstream effect of callow political leadership. In his reflection on the fifth anniversary of the start of the COVID pandemic, science writer David Wallace-Wells identified a pattern of “survivor’s resentment”–anger that protecting each other imposed costs on us; we resent having had to do the work of caring. In backlash, we flaunt how much we’re not required to care for each other by cutting off others in traffic, declining to mask when we see others doing it, or generally prioritizing our preferences over others’ needs.
In this moment, when it feels like fellow drivers, colleagues, customers and customer service reps, students, parents, fellow shoppers at the grocery store, people I’m trying to share the sidewalk with, almost everyone on social media, and virtually all politicians are ruder, cruder, and more selfish, I’ve turned to the Apostle Paul, who was pretty skilled in helping people get along. (Paul and I have had a contentious relationship, but when I see him not as a theologian but as an organizer, my appreciation grows.) In 1 Corinthians 10, he writes the script of our internal monologue when we are experiencing survivor’s resentment:
“I have the right to do anything,” you say–but not everything is beneficial. “I have the right to do anything”–but not everything is constructive. No one should seek their own good, but the good of others.
Paul understands the temptation to shout “My rights!” and “I’ve already done my share!” and “It’s not fair!” But exercising our right can include declining our preferences when they make life harder for others. Paul directs us to seek the good of others, not advantage over them. This is even more the case when we are more mature, safer, or stronger than them and thus can easier relent of our desires than they can of theirs. Or, as Paul says in Romans 15:
We who are strong ought to bear with the failings of the weak and not to please ourselves.
These words are encouraging because they point me toward actions that reduce my anger and others’ refusal to care. Can I bear with an entitled student? An employee doing a lackadaisical job? Someone being an asshole on the internet? Sure, I have the right to complain, to assign an F or try to get them fired or cuss them out. But if I take Paul’s advice and seek their good, the situation almost always changes. I’m in problem-solving mode rather than rights-exercising mode, and I’m less angry, and that makes the whole encounter less angry.
This is not a cure-all–Our problems are big and rooted in an ableism that runs across the political spectrum and takes forms both rude and polite–but it is one strategy. We would love to hear yours as we struggle together for a kinder, more just world.
With love, on behalf of the larger B-F family,
Rebecca
PS. Want to hear a beautiful song? Listen to Guy Clark’s “Stuff that Works.” And share with us your own “Stuff that works, stuff that holds up/The kind of stuff you don’t hang on a wall/Stuff that’s real, stuff you feel/The kind of stuff you reach for when you fall.” We would be honored to hear about what you hold dear.
The time of Advent, Christmas, and Epiphany, which we celebrate through the Presentation of the Lord at the Temple (so, from December 1 to February 2 this year) encompasses a season of long nights, including the winter solstice. By now, we see the sun setting a little later in the day, which brings relief to many of my friends, but I love this time of year, when our reason to light candles and turn on the Christmas lights starts at 5:15 pm.
We light lights, and we find lights, especially in our neighborhoods and in public places.
We celebrate the birth of Jesus, the start of Mary and Joseph’s life as parents, the hope of the Magnificat, and the work of our faith.
We decorate trees with reminders of people and places we love.
Our church invites people to submit reflections/activities/encouraging words to be shared via email during Advent. Each of us wrote one, and I think you can hear our voices very clearly in them.
From me:
Mary Elizabeth Coleridge was a British novelist and essayist who wrote in the late 19th and early 20th century, but she is best remembered now for her poetry. Her work often has a mystical element to it, like in this simple, short poem about Christmas with a shocking last line that reminds me of the Magnificat’s promise:
“I Saw a Stable”
I saw a stable, low and very bare,
A little child in a manger.
The oxen knew Him, had Him in their care,
To men He was a stranger.
The safety of the world was lying there,
And the world’s danger.
Much of Coleridge’s poetry has been set to music, including this poem. You can listen to it here:
From the youngest: I like a sketch comedy show called Studio C. It’s a good fit for kids but my whole family likes it. They made a Christmas Compilation. It’s an hour long, but you can watch just one skit when you need a little laugh.
From the middle child:
Ever since I was little, my favorite holiday has been Christmas. I’m simply enamored by the sparkling lights and the excitement in the atmosphere. But I struggle with the arrival of the holiday. For me, the buildup is almost better than the actual day! Because when the day comes, I’m struck by the fact that I must wait another year for the excitement and cheer of waiting. The gifts are not my favorite part. It’s the sense of togetherness I gain from being excited for something with other people! I guess that makes Advent my favorite time of year, even more than Christmas!
And from the oldest:
A favorite part of this holiday, for me, is its fascinating cultural history. From its early beginnings as a way to absorb and de-paganize solstice festivals to Charles Dickens nearly single-handedly bringing it back into vogue, Christmas has had its ups and downs.
To me, the most humorous part of Christmas’s long history is Oliver Cromwell’s–Lord Protector, commander of the New Model Army, and all around most puritan of Puritans–War on Christmas. Now, it technically is a little facetious to say that Oliver Cromwell banned Christmas. What actually happened was that the extremely Protestant Roundhead faction (and I mean Protestant in the “Witchfinder General”/“Popish plot” kind of way) beat the monarchists in the English Civil War. Suddenly, real, classic Puritanism in its most fun-hating form takes control of the country, and Cromwell, their leader, appoints himself dictator and begins a war with Ireland that basically amounts to an attempted genocide, executes the king, and crushes a Scottish rebellion, but more important for our story, he implements a series of extremely harsh restrictions on celebrations and veneration of saints. Basically, he sees the myriad celebrations and feasting held in honor of saints, the largest among them being Christmas, and he, because most of England was seeing Catholics in the shadows and Frenchmen in the walls, declared the holiday to be “pagan” and “popish.” He banned reverie and celebration, passing an ordinance that people should treat December generally and Christmas in particular “with the more solemn humiliation because it may call to remembrance our sins, and the sins of our forefathers, who have turned this feast, pretending the memory of Christ, into an extreme forgetfulness of him, by giving liberty to carnal and sensual delights.” (You do celebrate Christmas this way, right?) This deeply angered the public, triggering a weeks-long period of pro-Christmas rioting/general merriment that Cromwell was unable to control. Eventually, Cromwell would go on to die, have his body be dug up, hanged at Tyburn, and then beheaded, his decapitated head eventually stuck on a stake in front of Westminster Hall, a harsh punishment even for this true enemy of Christmas.
All in all, an anecdote in the history that reminds us that this wondrous season hasn’t always been Coke polar bears and mall Santas. It combines a few of my favorite historical topics: weird Puritans, anti-governmental rioting, and of course, Christmas!
This children’s time teaching shares information about childbirth in first century Palestine. Learn about what Mary might have experienced, how she was supported, and how baby Jesus was cared for when he was just born.
My grandparents give me lousy Christmas presents each year. They are either things I’m not interested in or presents that are for kids younger than me. (I’m 10.) I know it’s the thought that counts, but my grandparents don’t really seem to be thinking about me when they give me these gifts. Should I just pretend I like their presents or tell them how I really feel?
Don’t Call Me Ungrateful, Please
Dear Not Ungrateful,
In my opinion, the best option would be to either subtly imply that you would like something more to your liking, for next time, or simply return the presents to the store where they were purchased. If they were from a big box store, such as Walmart or Target, buy something you would prefer to the lackluster gifts. Your grandparents are far away and probably won’t notice that you don’t own their gifts anymore.
—
Mr.Prickles
******************
Dear Not Ungrateful,
First, let me say I LOVE the double negative in your pseudonym! But, graver topics are on the floor: Christmas presents.
If you feel like the fits aren’t a good fit for you, then it means that your grandparents are struggling to buy or make what you would like. Help them out by giving them ideas! Decide on one kind of thing that your grandparents could give you and ask for that year after year (or until you grow out of it).
For example, maybe there is a series of books you love (The Nathan Hale series is a good choice if you like history and graphic novels!) or a kind of book you like (like stories about World War II). Many schools participate in Scholastic Book Clubs. Create an account and a wishlist, then share it with your grandparents. They can buy the books online and have them shipped to your school, and when they order books this way, your classroom gets free books from Scholastic.
Or maybe there is a kind of art supply you like and could always use more of. Things that get used up (paints, crayons, sketchbooks, fancy teas, bubble bath) are things you can always use.
Communication is the key here. You can tell them what you want without sounding greedy. Try this: “One of my goals for next year is to get better at crocheting so I’m asking people who usually buy me presents to help stock my supply of yarn” or “This year, I’ve really gotten into history, especially the Civil Rights period. If you were thinking about buying me a present, I’d love to read more about this time period.”
Check in with us next year to let us know how this works out for you!
Lamb
******************
Dear Not Grateful,
You are kind to care about your grandparents’ feelings.
This isn’t a problem about Christmas, I think. It’s a problem about the rest of the year. Your grandparents don’t seem to know you well enough to give you a present based on your interests. Let them know what interests you far in advance of Christmas. Better yet, get them interested with you Even though they are far away, you can share some interests in common. For example:
Play online chess or another online game together
Make a craft together (like each of you piecing half of the squares of a quilt).
Set aside time after your favorite football teams play to discuss the game over Skype or Facetime.
If you perform in a concert or play, send your grandparents a video of it.
Take photos of the artwork you make in school and ask your parents to post them online where your grandparents can see them.
Ask your parents to buy you a set of 12 nice notecards and 12 stamps, then paperclip a stamped, addressed envelope with a blank card inside to each month of your calendar. Each time something exciting happens that month, write a short note inside the card (“Band concert today–We played music from Harry Potter!” or “Lost our basketball game tonight, but I scored more points in a single game than I ever have!” or “Earned an A+ on my Newberry Honor diarama!”) several times each week, then mail the card at the end of the month.
As your grandparents get to know what you are good at and what you enjoy, they will become better gift-givers. Best of all, you will get to know each other better!