Holiday Advice: Ideas for Hostess Gifts

This post is part of a short series about having a happy holiday. It’s inspired by questions posted in my parent support group, shared here with permission and without identifying details. If you have a question–or a solution to one!–to share, let me know.

Here is today’s question, plus some follow-ups:

I’m at a loss when it comes to host/hostess gifts. Can you offer some suggestions?

A host/hostess gift thanks someone for their hospitality–their invitation for you to join them in their home, which is an act of vulnerability and generosity. We recognize their efforts in preparing their home, making food, and ensuring our comfort and safety with a small gift.

A good host/hostess gift is one that

  • is sincerely given
  • isn’t so expensive as to be a burden to you or an embarrassment to the recipient
  • is for the host/hostess only, to be given to them without expectation that they share it with the group
  • is never a criticism or suggests that they might not be prepared (for example, handing them a bottle of wine or a serving utensil and saying, “This is in case you don’t have enough”)
  • does not presume a level of intimacy that doesn’t exist between you (for example, no personal care items unless you know the person very well)
  • is not something to be displayed unless, again, you know them very well–and even then, is small (like a Christmas ornament)
  • is typically consumable, so they can use it, share it, or regift it easily

Some gifts are best if you know the person very well, while others are suitable even if it’s your first time in someone’s home. Here are our favorites to give and receive:

  • higher-end nuts, chocolates, or candies–nicer than what is typically at your grocery store
  • cut flowers already in a vase–better if it’s a pretty one you score from a thrift store rather than one from the floral department of the grocery store
  • old-fashioned holiday candies, like ribbon candies
  • a small fruit basket (Kumquats are a favorite to share!)
  • a 0 proof wine or apéritif if you don’t know if they consume alcohol or a bottle of wine or liqueur if you know that they do
  • a 4- or 6-pack of fun sodas
  • a box of fancy tea or pound of fancy coffee
  • a locally made favorite: pfeffernüsse, pecans or chestnuts from a local orchard, popcorn from local growers
  • if they aren’t from around where they live, a favorite from where they’re from. Someone once sent me grilled stickies from Ye Old College Diner (RIP) in State College, Pennsylvania, while I lived far away, and they will be mentioned in my obituary.
grilled stickies in a box

Above, a dessert that you didn’t know you needed. Be a pal and order some for the central Pennsylvanians you love who are far from home.

If you know someone well, you can consider:

  • one more item in a series of something that they collect (book, kitchen tool, refrigerator magnet)
  • a framed photo of people or a place they love–maybe even with them in it!
  • a houseplant, including a cutting from one of yours
  • an amaryllis, small pointsettia, or other holiday-specific plant
  • a jar of jam or bottle of real maple syrup
  • an ingredient they’d enjoy cooking with but aren’t likely to already own (specialty flour, high-end spice)
  • something homemade: a spice blend, a jar of salsa, your famous hot sauce, a table runner, potpourri that you made, dried flowers, a bottle of homemade Irish cream
  • something small that you noticed them enjoying in a previous encounter–like a magnet from your visit to the art museum, a small kitchen tool of yours that they complimented when they visited you

I prefer not to receive a hostess gift. How do I tell people not to bring one?

It is good that people desire to express their appreciation for your work as host, so be sure you have a significant reason for saying no, one that doesn’t dismiss their appreciation (“It’s no big deal to host!”) or insult them (“I already have enough junk in my house and don’t need more!”). If you do have a good reason and if you know someone well, you can tell them that you prefer for them to say thanks with words, not a gift. If you don’t know someone well, let them bring you a gift.

If you receive a gift you don’t want, say “Thank you!” without lying that it’s perfect or that you love it or that it’s thoughtful. Then, give it away. Drop it off in your local neighborhood sharing box (“Blessing Box,” in some communities), advertise it for free on Facebook Marketplace (setting the settings so that your friends can’t see it), put it in the common area at your workplace with a sign that says “free,” or regift it to your child’s teacher, your church secretary, the janitor at work, your mail carrier, your garbarge collector, etc. Even if you are irritated that you received a gift you didn’t want, sharing a gift is a chance for you to think about the people in your life who would enjoy it, which is a good practice!

How do I handle a hostess gift that is clearly intended to be shared with the group?

If you want to share it, share it. If you don’t–maybe because it’s alcohol and this event is alcohol-free or because you have the perfect menu planned and this item interrupts it–say, “Thank you! I’m going to go put this away to enjoy later.” If the item is clearly for the moment–like a pan of dinner rolls or a pie–just say, “Thank you! I’m going to put this in the freezer so we can enjoy it later.” When you do enjoy it later, send them a text thanking them for it.

I think this is an important practice because some people really struggle not to impose their food on your menu. Whether this is because they are controlling or because they like helping (remembering that “helping is often the sunny side of control”), it’s a bad habit, and you shouldn’t cater to it.

Is it okay to regift a hostess gift?

Gifts are meant to be enjoyed, so if passing one along is how you enjoy, that’s just great! Just be sure that 1. the giver won’t see you do it, 2. the recipient is likely to enjoy it, and 3. you remove any indicators that it is a regift. Then, give it away while enjoying the idea of it being appreciated by someone else.

100 gifts that are (almost) always a hit with kids

I’m not a recreational shopper typically, but I enjoy choosing gifts from my loved ones that they will enjoy. It’s a chance to think about them more deeply and a reminder to pay attention to what brings them pleasure. For kids, especially if you live far from them, this can be hard. Here is my go-to list for fun presents to send to kids. Of course, it’s best if you select what the children in your life have shown you that they love, and you should know that the adults who spend time with them will appreciate it too; no one wants to give a gift that will feel like a burden. Here are our ideas, and we’d love to hear yours!

  1. construction paper
  2. scissors with funky edges 
  3. glue sticks of different colors
  4. scented crayons or markers
  5. high-end colored pencils
  6. art pencils and a high quality eraser
  7. gel pens or Sharpies
  8. an art easel
  9. sketch books of various sizes
  10. a satchel for carrying art supplies
  11. cannisters for art supplies
  12. an electric pencil sharpener
  13. a high quality journal
  14. a journal with a lock and key
  15. a coin counting piggy bank
  16. a ceramic bank of a favorite animal
  17. a small safe
  18. a lockbox with a key
  19. a fireproof envelope for special documents
  20. a photo album with pictures of them
  21. a time capsule for them to make
  22. a time capsule with things about them inside
  23. fuzzy socks
  24. funny socks
  25. new mittens with clips to hang them on their coat
  26. gloves that can work with a touch screen
  27. long johns or footie pajamas
  28. a body pillow or a boyfriend pillow
  29. a bean bag chair 
  30. a book lamp
  31. a handcrank flashlight
  32. a handcrank radio
  33. a water bottle, mug, thermos, or travel mug
  34. fruit leather
  35. dehydrated strawberries or raspberries
  36. kumquats
  37. cheddar cheese or caramel popcorn
  38. snack food from another country
  39. movie theater sized boxes of candy
  40. walkie talkies
  41. a tent
  42. a hammock
  43. a canteen
  44. a sleeping bag
  45. a humidifier that uses essential oils, plus some oils
  46. nail polish
  47. Working Hands hand cream
  48. mud masks
  49. lip gloss
  50. lip balm
  51. shaving supplies
  52. a roll of quarters to use in vending machines
  53. a monogrammed apron 
  54. a kid-sized suitcase
  55. a wallet
  56. a purse
  57. a magazine subscription
  58. fancy stationary
  59. post card stamps
  60. hard-to-find candies or sodas
  61. vegan beef jerky
  62. an age-appropriate cookbook
  63. an address book filled out with addresses you know they will want
  64. a perpetual calendar where they can write birthdays of friends
  65. a pop socket
  66. a magnetic phone mount (for those old enough to drive)
  67. a power bank
  68. a very fancy bookmark
  69. Stretch Armstrong and his dog Fetch Armstrong
  70. the book that won this year’s Caldecott, Newberry, Coretta Scott King, Batchelder (for foreign language book translated into English), Geisel Medal, Belpre Medal, Odyssey, Hornbook, Ezra Jack Keats, Charlotte Zolotow, or Hornbook awards
  71. a pop-up tunnel for use inside
  72. a swing
  73. a “flexible flyer” style sled
  74. a red runner sled
  75. a toboggan 
  76. a snow tube sled
  77. a record player with records
  78. the board game that won this year’s Game of the Year
  79. retro games for their current game system
  80. Rubik’s cube
  81. Dutch Blitz
  82. Parcheesi or another classic game they don’t have
  83. Uno or, if they already have it, Skip Bo or Duo
  84. a small electric blanket
  85. a water bottle or rice bag that you heat and put in your bed
  86. new sheets with their favorite characters on them
  87. a houseplant
  88. a birdhouse, bird feeder with food or a suet feeder, or bird bath
  89. a bat house
  90. a new soccer or basketball with air pump, if they don’t already have one
  91. a yoga ball or a yoga mat
  92. a fun night light
  93. an alarm clock
  94. a new percussion instrument, like jingle bells or claves or a woodblock or hand drums
  95. unusual teas and a tea strainer
  96. spice mixes for popcorn
  97. a pocketknife, Swiss army knife, or leatherman
  98. a microscope
  99. a telescope
  100. binoculars
Above, our tree on the night before Christmas, 2020.