Holiday Advice: Ideas for Hostess Gifts

This post is part of a short series about having a happy holiday. It’s inspired by questions posted in my parent support group, shared here with permission and without identifying details. If you have a question–or a solution to one!–to share, let me know.

Here is today’s question, plus some follow-ups:

I’m at a loss when it comes to host/hostess gifts. Can you offer some suggestions?

A host/hostess gift thanks someone for their hospitality–their invitation for you to join them in their home, which is an act of vulnerability and generosity. We recognize their efforts in preparing their home, making food, and ensuring our comfort and safety with a small gift.

A good host/hostess gift is one that

  • is sincerely given
  • isn’t so expensive as to be a burden to you or an embarrassment to the recipient
  • is for the host/hostess only, to be given to them without expectation that they share it with the group
  • is never a criticism or suggests that they might not be prepared (for example, handing them a bottle of wine or a serving utensil and saying, “This is in case you don’t have enough”)
  • does not presume a level of intimacy that doesn’t exist between you (for example, no personal care items unless you know the person very well)
  • is not something to be displayed unless, again, you know them very well–and even then, is small (like a Christmas ornament)
  • is typically consumable, so they can use it, share it, or regift it easily

Some gifts are best if you know the person very well, while others are suitable even if it’s your first time in someone’s home. Here are our favorites to give and receive:

  • higher-end nuts, chocolates, or candies–nicer than what is typically at your grocery store
  • cut flowers already in a vase–better if it’s a pretty one you score from a thrift store rather than one from the floral department of the grocery store
  • old-fashioned holiday candies, like ribbon candies
  • a small fruit basket (Kumquats are a favorite to share!)
  • a 0 proof wine or apéritif if you don’t know if they consume alcohol or a bottle of wine or liqueur if you know that they do
  • a 4- or 6-pack of fun sodas
  • a box of fancy tea or pound of fancy coffee
  • a locally made favorite: pfeffernüsse, pecans or chestnuts from a local orchard, popcorn from local growers
  • if they aren’t from around where they live, a favorite from where they’re from. Someone once sent me grilled stickies from Ye Old College Diner (RIP) in State College, Pennsylvania, while I lived far away, and they will be mentioned in my obituary.
grilled stickies in a box

Above, a dessert that you didn’t know you needed. Be a pal and order some for the central Pennsylvanians you love who are far from home.

If you know someone well, you can consider:

  • one more item in a series of something that they collect (book, kitchen tool, refrigerator magnet)
  • a framed photo of people or a place they love–maybe even with them in it!
  • a houseplant, including a cutting from one of yours
  • an amaryllis, small pointsettia, or other holiday-specific plant
  • a jar of jam or bottle of real maple syrup
  • an ingredient they’d enjoy cooking with but aren’t likely to already own (specialty flour, high-end spice)
  • something homemade: a spice blend, a jar of salsa, your famous hot sauce, a table runner, potpourri that you made, dried flowers, a bottle of homemade Irish cream
  • something small that you noticed them enjoying in a previous encounter–like a magnet from your visit to the art museum, a small kitchen tool of yours that they complimented when they visited you

I prefer not to receive a hostess gift. How do I tell people not to bring one?

It is good that people desire to express their appreciation for your work as host, so be sure you have a significant reason for saying no, one that doesn’t dismiss their appreciation (“It’s no big deal to host!”) or insult them (“I already have enough junk in my house and don’t need more!”). If you do have a good reason and if you know someone well, you can tell them that you prefer for them to say thanks with words, not a gift. If you don’t know someone well, let them bring you a gift.

If you receive a gift you don’t want, say “Thank you!” without lying that it’s perfect or that you love it or that it’s thoughtful. Then, give it away. Drop it off in your local neighborhood sharing box (“Blessing Box,” in some communities), advertise it for free on Facebook Marketplace (setting the settings so that your friends can’t see it), put it in the common area at your workplace with a sign that says “free,” or regift it to your child’s teacher, your church secretary, the janitor at work, your mail carrier, your garbarge collector, etc. Even if you are irritated that you received a gift you didn’t want, sharing a gift is a chance for you to think about the people in your life who would enjoy it, which is a good practice!

How do I handle a hostess gift that is clearly intended to be shared with the group?

If you want to share it, share it. If you don’t–maybe because it’s alcohol and this event is alcohol-free or because you have the perfect menu planned and this item interrupts it–say, “Thank you! I’m going to go put this away to enjoy later.” If the item is clearly for the moment–like a pan of dinner rolls or a pie–just say, “Thank you! I’m going to put this in the freezer so we can enjoy it later.” When you do enjoy it later, send them a text thanking them for it.

I think this is an important practice because some people really struggle not to impose their food on your menu. Whether this is because they are controlling or because they like helping (remembering that “helping is often the sunny side of control”), it’s a bad habit, and you shouldn’t cater to it.

Is it okay to regift a hostess gift?

Gifts are meant to be enjoyed, so if passing one along is how you enjoy, that’s just great! Just be sure that 1. the giver won’t see you do it, 2. the recipient is likely to enjoy it, and 3. you remove any indicators that it is a regift. Then, give it away while enjoying the idea of it being appreciated by someone else.

Having a Happy Holiday: Hostesses Who Can’t Relax

This post is part of a short series about having a happy holiday, one where you aren’t exhausted by or resentful of the work needed, everyone gets to participate in ways that satisfy, and your values and traditions–and effort and money–are respected. It’s inspired by questions posted my parent support group, shared here with permission and without identifying details. If you have a question–or a solution to one!–to share, let me know.

In this post, we’re sharing challenges we’ve faced in creating a happy Thanksgiving, Christmas, or other major holiday, in hopes that others can benefit from our experiences. We’re drawing on our childhood and adult experiences, with a focus on the diverse needs of guests and the challenges of helping everyone, regardless of age, having a fun time.

Here’s today’s challenge:

While typically a normal human being, my mother is highly stressed when hosting and passes that along to others. It’s clear that she doesn’t enjoy hosting events, but she also won’t let anyone else take over the duties. We dread going to her house for the holidays. She works through the entire event, but instead of feeling cared for, we feel like we’re a burden. For example, last year, she whisked away my dessert plate while I was still eating my pie! We’re not allowed to eat in the dining room because she got new carpet in it 15 years ago and doesn’t want stains on it, so we end up perched on couches and folding chairs throughout the house, and then she’s anxious that we’re going to spill our food there, too. Instead of eating, she walks around with a Dustbuster in her hand sweeping up crumbs. It’s misery.

Graciously remember that many generations of women likely faced (and saw their mothers face) a lot of judgment about being an “angel of the house,” and they have internalized it–and may also externalize it by being judgmental about other women’s performances of hosting. But the reality is that it’s hard to be gracious to a Thankzilla when she’s raging against both internalized sexism and her guests, even if that rage is the quiet seething of someone who is unloading the dishwasher that you loaded after the dishes have been through the wash cycle, rinsing them, and then reloading it and re-starting the entire dishwasher process because, without her supervision, you surely did not properly scrape and rinse the dishes before loading the dishwasher in the first place. (Ooops. I think we’ve touched a nerve here for me!)

Yeah, it’s hard to be the object of resentment while also being seen as too incompetent to perform any tasks that would lighten her burden.

While I’m not recommending Bad Moms, Christine Baranaski’s character is the epitome of a controlling, insecure mom at the holidays. My favorite line is when she tells her adult daughter “Moms don’t ENjoy; they GIVE joy. That’s how being a mom works and this hideous tree does not give joy to anybody.”

There is no solving her problem, unfortunately, because if you do manage to get her to release control, she will feel guilty about enjoying her day; her anxiety and resentment are, to her, measures of her success; she cannot fathom that she did a good job unless she feels like she is suffering.

The only way to win at this game is not to play. So, to that extent:

  • drop the holiday gathering from your rotation of times when you see her. You can see her at a time when the pressure is lower on her, creating a new tradition at a different time of year. You can celebrate a holiday that you love in a way that makes sense for your family. Yes, this will hurt her feelings, but you can say honestly, “I want something different from my Thanksgiving than we’re able to do together, so our family won’t be coming this year. We’d love to do X [a luminary walk at the arboretum, attend the town Thanksgiving Day parade, attend a performance of Amahl and the Night Visitors, participate in the Audubon Society’s annual bird count, sing in the community choir’s performance of Handel’s Messiah, etc.] with you instead.” Be clear that it’s not a scheduling issue as she’ll try to solve it, which only kicks the problem down the road.
  • host the event. If she asks how she can help, give her a specific task that she will actually enjoy, along with a compliment about it; the key here is that it has to have some level of challenge to it so it will help dissipate her anxious energy. (“You always make the best pumpkin roll! Would you like to make one for the event?” “The kids love your cookies! Could you bake sugar cookies for the kids to decorate, with your help, after the meal while I do the dishes? I’ll bring the icing and the decorations if you bake them.” “We’d like to take a family photo. Could you find a photographer and schedule them for a mini-session at our house? And let everyone know to come dressed for photos. We’ll pay, and the budget is XXX.” “You set such a beautiful table! Could you bring a centerpiece?”)
  • offer to host, but shift to a nice restaurant, and pay for her meal without telling her the cost. Tell her that it’s a thank you for all the times she’s hosted. If she complains that it costs too much to eat out, tell her, “You’re worth every penny!” Tip the waitstaff HUGELY and, again, don’t tell your mother/MIL. And if she says that she’ll tip them, let her, but them tip them again anyway because they deserve a huge tip at a holiday and probably had to absorb your mother/MIL’s anxious energy and criticism too.
  • if she insists on hosting, suggest a breakfast or dessert event, which will limit the amount of time spent together, or quickly transition from a meal to something outdoors, like a family walk at a local county park or volunteering at a soup kitchen, so that time spent in her home is limited.
  • if she hosts, remember that you don’t have to attend or stay very long. You can enjoy as much of the day as you enjoy, then leave. Or you can even make plans to leave early because of another event, like volunteering or visiting a shut-in friend or relative. Drive separately from your partner if needed to ensure a quick getaway.
  • if she hosts and you choose to participate, ask early how you can help, then do that thing early, giving her updates once it’s done so that her anxiety about whether you are going to deliver is soothed (“I made the cheese balls last weekend, and they’re in the freezer, just waiting for the big day!”) If you live nearby, offer to drop food or other items off early, like the day before, so she can organize them as she pleases. When en route, call and ask if she needs any last minute items, like additional ice or more butter or a box of plastic flatware, which shows that you understand the stress of hosting.

Also, bring a hostess gift that she will actually enjoy–cut flowers already in a vase, a little plant, some pretty stationary, a favorite candy. When you arrive, take her aside and give it to her, letting her know that it’s just for her, to be opened whenever she likes. If she wants to share the box of chocolates or bottle of wine with everyone, that’s up to her, but it should be something that demonstrates that you know her well and appreciate her. Because, even when she’s melting down because someone has violated an unspoken rule, you actually do appreciate her. At least, on other days.

Have a question, challenge, or piece of advice to share about how to enjoy holidays? Please share it!

Foxhole Advice: I want to watch scary movies. And I also DON’T want to watch scary movies.

Dear Family Foxhole,

I’m embarrassed to admit it, but I’m twelve and do not like to watch the scary movies that my friends enjoy. Right now, if I go to a friend’s house and they want to watch something scary, I just say that I’m not allowed to watch PG-13 movies (which isn’t quite true; my parents let me watch some PG-13 movies but not others) and then we all roll our eyes and say that my parents ruin all our fun, then watch something else. But I’ll be 13 soon, so this lie isn’t going to work anymore!

How can I overcome my fear of scary movies so I’m not left out?

Scaredy-Cat

Dear Scaredy-Cat,

Before the party, suggest a list of movies for the party that provide your friends with enough choices that they don’t even realize that there’s nothing scary on the list. You could include some PG-13 movies that aren’t scary (comedies, romantic comedies, superhero movies).

Plan a party yourself! Pick a theme that is upbeat (“Surf’s Up!” or “Dinner is Served!”) and organize the food, decoration, games, and movie around that theme. You can set the expectation among your friends that parties will be fun and positive. If, later on, someone plans a party around a scary theme, just go for the first part (before the movie starts) and then tell them you have a super-important meeting in the morning (Be mysterious!) and need to get your beauty rest.  You won’t be missing out on the fun since you wouldn’t be having fun anyway.

Lamb

Lamb

************************

Dear Scaredy-Cat,

Creep out your friends by saying, “I can’t watch [whatever movie it is]. It brings back too many memories.” Then get a faraway look in your eye, then shake your head, like you’re trying to forget about that time a creepy girl crawled out of your TV to eat your face off.

Also, always bring a book wherever you go. Once the scary movie starts, just sneak away to read. If anyone catches you, just say that you thought that movie was boring. Be disdainful and give a big yawn. Try something like: “Once you’ve seen as many horror movies as I have, it’s hard to be surprised.” Be the stereotype of the disinterested, bored teen. Use it to your advantage, then get back to your book.

Mr. Prickles

Mr. Prickles

************************

Dear Scaredy-Cat

You don’t have to overcome your fear. Some adults don’t like scary movies. It’s not a sign of maturity. In fact, that you know yourself this well is a sign of maturity!

However, if you do want to join in, ask the title of the movie they’ll be watching before the party. Ask a parent to watch it for you and tell you about all the scary parts. If there is a certain kind of scary activity that you can’t stand (jump scares, gore, monsters, scary children, meanness to animals, etc.), be sure to tell them to be on the lookout for these things. Then watch it together. As a scary part approaches, stop the video and ask them to tell you what is going to happen. You might even watch it in fast forward to see what happens without the sound on.

I’m a grown-up, and I still watch any movies this way!

Honey

Honey